Our Carriers

Anthem insurance carrier logo and shield symbol.
Aultcare insurance carrier logo, partner of Buell & Olivieri Insurance Agency
Auto-Owners Insurance logo representing life, home, car, and business coverage.
Chubb insurance carrier logo and branding for Buell & Olivieri agency.
CNA insurance carrier logo, Buell & Olivieri partner.
Grange Insurance logo representing a partner carrier for Buell & Olivieri.
Hagerty car insurance logo and branding for classic car insurance.
Liberty Mutual Insurance logo, a top-rated carrier partnered with Buell & Olivieri.
Lloyd's insurance carrier logo, Buell & Olivieri partner.
Medical Mutual logo, a partner carrier for Buell & Olivieri Insurance Agency
Progressive insurance carrier logo, independent insurance broker partners
Summa Health insurance carrier logo and branding.
Travelers Insurance logo with umbrella symbol, top-rated insurance carrier
Western Reserve Group logo, insurance carrier partnered with Buell & Olivieri.

FAQS

What makes Buell & Olivieri different from other insurance agencies?

Most insurance agencies you see on TV are "captive" agencies, meaning they work for one corporate company and can only sell that company’s specific policies. We are an independent insurance broker. We don't report to a corporate insurance giant—we report to you. Because we handle seven different top-rated carriers, we can shop the whole market to find the best policy for your specific needs and budget, rather than forcing you into a cookie-cutter plan.

How much does it cost for you to shop multiple carriers for me?

Exactly $0.00. There is absolutely no fee or extra charge for us to run your information through our different carriers. We do all the heavy lifting—comparing rates, checking the fine print, and finding the best value—as a standard part of our service to you.

What happens if I need to file a claim? Do I have to deal with the insurance company alone?

Not at all. This is where the value of a local broker truly shines. We provide claims advocacy, which means if you have an accident or damage to your home, you call us first. We help you navigate the paperwork, explain the process in plain English, and stand by your side to make sure the insurance carrier treats you fairly and pays out what you are owed. You get a real local advocate in your corner, not a random automated phone tree.

How long has Buell & Olivieri been in business?

We have been proudly protecting individuals, families, and businesses in Ohio since 1960. Over the last six decades, the insurance industry has changed drastically, but our core mission hasn't: providing steady, reliable, and honest guidance to our neighbors through every stage of life.

How is the agency involved in the local community?

We don't just work here; we live here, raise our families here, and pour back into the neighborhood. We are deeply committed to supporting local small businesses, schools, and civic organizations. You’ll frequently see us partnering with local mainstays—like the Divine Mercy Parish in Massillon, Jackson High School, Canton Central Catholic High School and the YMCA—and highlighting the stories of our local "Dreamers" on social media. We believe a strong community makes everyone safer and more prosperous.

Why should I choose Buell & Olivieri over a fast online quote tool?

An online algorithm doesn't know you, your family, or the specific risks of our local area. It only knows how to give you the cheapest price, which usually means leaving you dangerously underinsured when you actually need to file a claim.
When you choose us, you get the best of both worlds: the competitive pricing of 7 different preferred top-rated carriers, backed by a dedicated, local human being who knows your name. We save you time, eliminate the guesswork, and give you true peace of mind.

Buell & Olivieri Insurance logo and branding for auto insurance inquiries.

2026 by Buell & Olivieri Insurance